Defensive doubts: Should Tuchel turn to Guehi after Croatia wobble?

England's front line lit up the Dallas humidity against Croatia, but for every moment of attacking spark, there was a defensive jitter. The Three Lions may have found goals, but the backline looked anything but assured. With the possibility of Thomas Tuchel taking the managerial reins, the centre‑back dilemma has become a burning topic—and Marc Guehi is emerging as a prime candidate.

Defensive concerns

The friendly in Texas offered plenty of encouragement in the final third, but the defensive unit left question marks. Against a Croatia side lacking some of its usual firepower, England's rearguard still looked vulnerable, with gaps appearing and communication lacking. It was a reminder that when the opposition raises the tempo, this backline can be exposed. Fans and pundits alike have started to wonder whether the current pairing can hold up in a major tournament.

The Guehi option

Step forward Marc Guehi. The Crystal Palace centre‑back has been steadily building a reputation as one of the Premier League's most dependable defenders. Composed on the ball, strong in the tackle, and with a reading of the game that belies his age, Guehi offers a calm presence. His performances at club level have drawn consistent praise, and many argue he deserves a stronger look in an England shirt. For a side that sometimes looks shaky under pressure, Guehi's composure could be exactly what's needed.

Tuchel's tactical impact

If Thomas Tuchel does step into the England role, his defensive philosophy will be centre stage. The German tactician is known for demanding discipline, structure, and intelligent positioning from his backline. He often favours a centre‑back who can step into midfield and initiate attacks—a profile Guehi fits well. Tuchel's previous work with defenders like Antonio Rüdiger shows he values speed and reading of the game. Guehi's ability to play in a high line and his comfort on the ball make him a natural fit for such a system. The debate is not just about who starts next game, but about building a defence that can win a knockout tie.

What it means: The Croatia friendly exposed a fault line England must address. Whether it's Guehi or another candidate, the centre‑back partnership will define the team's ceiling. With Tuchel's potential arrival, the search for solidity takes on new urgency. The answer might already be playing at Selhurst Park.